• Home
  • About
    • The Film
    • Main Characters
    • Experts in the Film
    • Filmmakers’ Bios
    • Screening Tools
    • Selected Media Coverage
  • Learn More
    • Science
    • Vaccine Facts and FAQs
    • Books
    • Links
    • Vaccine Ingredients
  • Get Involved
  • Donate
  • News & Video
    • News & Views
    • Interviews
    • Vaccine Beat
    • Outtakes
    • Your Stories
  • Stream Movie
  • Buy DVD
  • Contact
    • Press
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • YouTube

The Greater Good Movie

a documentary film about vaccines in America

How to know when it’s time to fire your doctor

August 6, 2012,

This story was submitted by Shawna I. Clark:

I brought my son Xavier Pinder for an appointment on May, 7 2012 at Naval Hospital Oak Harbor pediatrics to be seen for a cough he has had for two weeks.  Our assigned pediatrician is Dr. Miller and we saw him on this day.  When Dr. Miller came into the exam room he asked what was going on with Xavier.  I explained to him about the cough, what it sounds like, that it seems to worsen as the day progresses and what over the counter medications I had been using to treat it.  Dr. Miller asked me how long this had been going on.  I told him that the coughing started as more mild type coughing symptoms that were coupled with a sore throat Xavier had been seen by him for two weeks earlier and that the cough has never gone away.

Dr. Miller had a folder and some papers in his hands that he threw onto the exam table where Xavier was sitting playing a game.  He said he wished he would have known about the coughing when he saw Xavier before because now he needed to swab him for pertussis since there was an outbreak.  Dr. Miller said that Xavier’s cough could be just a lingering cold or he could have pertussis in which case every time I (speaking to me) have taken Xavier to Walmart and he has coughed all over someone’s infant child I am potentially killing other people’s children.

He asked me to give him a reason why Xavier does not have any vaccinations on record.  I told Dr. Miller Xavier has never received a vaccination because I have made a choice as a parent not to vaccinate.  I told Dr. Miller that if he had something he felt he needed to inform me about I would listen however I was not going to discuss it or argue with him but I would be agreeable to listen.  Dr. Miller asked me if I knew the statistics on how many people die every year from not vaccinating.  I told him I did not and that I did not understand what the problem was, that I was doing nothing illegal, and that as a parent it is my choice.

I told Dr. Miller I did not understand why this was such a problem at Navy Hospital and that I was not treated like this elsewhere.  Dr. Miller asked me where else I have taken Xavier and I told him nowhere and he told me that was the reason.  I told Dr. Miller that I have an older child who does not come to Navy Hospital for treatment who is also not vaccinated and that his doctor treats me with dignity and respect.  Dr. Miller asked me to sign a waiver form and I refused.  I refused to sign the form because Dr. Miller outlined a list of vaccines on the form with his pen or pencil and said I would be signing that he informed me of the risks of not receiving those vaccinations.

Pages: 1 2

Filed Under: Your Stories

More of Your Stories

U-Tube video made me think

I was watching a video and heard a part that made me listen a little closer (4:40-5:20). This mom was talking about her son developing a fever and a rash after the MMR vaccine. I knew my son had … More

Emily’s family struggle with autism

My husband and I were blessed with the birth of our darling Emily on a very cold February morning in 2003. She was our second child and joined her older sister, Brittany, as a wonderful addition to … More

More of your stories

Comments

  1. KU says

    September 27, 2012 at 8:37 PM

    Nice work mom! I think it is our right to do as we like…and it is our responsibility to know what they are vaccinating our children against, so that if it is contagious we know the warning signs…we don’t need doctor’s offices to support the cures or the diagnosis of all childhood diseases. We also must learn that there are remedies that support health that do not come from the Dr office. In addition my understanding of pertusis is that after a week any antibiotics are virtually useless for helping the child heal and that the cough may not be contagious anymore…if anyone has any other information to counter this, please share with me…let’s inform ourselves and be thinkers about our health and take it back!

  2. Kim says

    September 30, 2012 at 1:25 AM

    Our pediatrician refuses to see us once we refuse a vaccine and I can’t find a list of pediatricians that accept non-vax parents. By the way, doctors receive awards, maybe even financial compensation, for most vaccines provided to patients.

Cart

Stream the Film

Buy the DVD

Join the Conversation

Explore the Science

Stay Connected.

Get on the list and get occasional email about vaccine policy and science.

Your information is never shared.

Greater Good Outtakes

Greater Good Outtakes 11: Judicial Corruption

Learn what really happened in Dr. Andrew Wakefield’s court case. https://youtu.be/GHvIFUNYs44 … More

Greater Good Outtakes 10: Ruined For Life

Congressman Dan Burton shares his personal vaccine injury story and his frustration in not being … More

More Outtakes

Vaccine Beat Videos

Vaccine Beat 5: Censorship

When you think of the Nazis do you think of liberty or tyranny? When you think of book burning do … More

Vaccine Beat 4: Living the American Dream

While Americans want to trust that health officials are acting in the best interests of the public, … More

More Vaccine Beat Videos

Reviews

THE GREATER GOOD may be the most important vaccine film ever made. Finally, we hear the stories of families adversely affected by vaccines told in a compelling and compassionate way. Using film as a medium for social change, THE GREATER GOOD informs, educates and calls to action. It is documentary film at its finest.
Peggy O'Mara
Wow. I was so riveted. The family stories were so heart wrenching. It was so well done. I hope this film is watched by many parents.
Dr. Bob Sears
THE GREATER GOOD is a truly important film, one that finally addresses the nuances of the great vaccine debate of our times. It is a moving and inspiring work that should be required viewing for health care practitioners and families interested in open and honest dialogue about immunizations and public health.
Dr. Larry Rosen
Electrifying.
Jessica
THE GREATER GOOD documentary provides real insights about the polarizing vaccine debate. The one size fits all, cradle to grave approach regarding vaccines is a short sighted crusade coordinated by the government and pharmaceutical companies. If we have learned anything regarding medical treatments, it’s that informed consent be the only mandatory requirement.
Dr. Joe Mercola
This film captures the essence of the vaccine debate: The benefits of vaccines for individuals as well as for society versus the very small but very real risks of a severe vaccine reaction. Everyone involved in the vaccine issue, from doctors and policymakers to every new parent, must see THE GREATER GOOD
Dr. Bob Sears
There are severe consequences due to our current vaccine policy and schedule, many of which are simply dismissed as coincidence or diagnosed improperly. These damages cannot be swept under the rug, and THE GREATER GOOD documentary highlights several powerful personal stories of vaccine tragedies to bring increased awareness to this important issue.
Dr. Joe Mercola
Vaccines: It is such an interesting topic, I’ve never experienced such a polarizing force in conversations or relationships.
Tony Edwards
There are many physicians who are witnessing an increasing number of children with complex inflammatory & autoimmune conditions, and are beginning to suspect that vaccines may be playing more of a contributing role in the development of these conditions, than what they were previously led to believe. Nonetheless, these physicians don’t have a safe forum in which they can discuss their concerns. This film, “THE GREATER GOOD,” may be the appropriate medium through which physicians can begin to open up the next phase of dialogue about their growing concerns of vaccine safety & efficacy.
Dr. Larry Palevsky

News & Views

Do You Notice a Pattern Here?

Do you notice a pattern here? Elites like Bill Gates and Henry Kissinger keep telling us we need a new world order, a new economy, and a new vaccine in order to rejoin life. And in case you missed … Watch

A Little Perspective

I am hoping that with some more information, people can relax a little so they can breathe and just focus on taking care of themselves. I don't want anyone to get sick or die, but panic makes those … Watch

No, it’s the MEDICAL-Military-Industrial Complex

We know from experience with SARS, bird flu, swine flu, Ebola, and Zika that the dangers and impact of these threats are often very exaggerated. Indeed, during the swine flu / H1N1 outbreak of 2009, … Watch

More

About Us

Leslie Manookian

Leslie Manookian
Writer / Producer

Kendall Nelson

Kendal Nelson
Director / Producer

All bios >>

Stay Connected

Keep in touch! Get the latest news, policy updates, and success stories!

Copyright © 2025 · Site by Epic Brand Media